top of page

The South rejects its role as America’s scapegoat

21 minutes ago
3 min read

Young Black southerners refuse stereotypes, confront the notion that they must leave home to succeed


On a highway, a highway sign points toward "the south" in large letters, with "the north" in smaller letters pointing in another direction. A car speeds down the highway toward "the south."
image credit: Sirita Render/Shutterstock

Sociologist and cultural critic, Tressie McMillan Cottom, has written about the comfort many Americans feel when comparing their region of the country to the South. This comparison often suggests that no matter how bad things are going in their neck of the woods, “at least we’re not as bad as (insert any Southern state here).” According to Cottom, these types of comments serve as a salve for the east and west coasters who (often) make them because they get to pretend by simply living elsewhere, they have managed to overcome many of the governmental shortcomings persistent in very visible ways in the American South.


[H]aving studied abroad while in undergrad and now maintaining friendships with peers from diverse backgrounds, She doesn’t believe simply leaving a place she loves for a place rumored to be “better” would solve any of the broken systems and weakened institutions impacting young people’s ability to thrive in the United States of 2026. 

Born and reared in Georgia, Jesus Denmark has also noticed others placing a geographic distance between themselves and the South. “It’s reductionist,” the 23-year-old Atlanta resident says. As a young woman just starting out in life, Denmark is sometimes confronted with the suggestion she should leave her home for a better life.


“Where a person is from holds a deeper connection to them than just politics and where to get a job,” she says. She knows, generally speaking, more progressive views and larger incomes exist in other regions of the country. However, having studied abroad while in undergrad and now maintaining friendships with peers from diverse backgrounds, she doesn’t believe simply leaving a place she loves for a place rumored to be “better” would solve any of the broken systems and weakened institutions impacting young people’s ability to thrive in the United States of 2026.


Jamee McAdoo is a 25-year-old woman who grew up in Little Rock, Ark.; she chose to return home after college. She’s well aware people stereotype her hometown as unintelligent and boring. McAdoo says, “(People) will say ‘what’s there to do in Little Rock besides go to Walmart or Sonic?”


The perception that small Southern towns don’t offer as much social and entertainment value as larger cities doesn’t bother McAdoo all that much. She’s more bothered by the assumption that because she’s from a small town in the South, she won’t achieve the same amount of success as others. “One misconception is that no one ‘makes it' from here,” she explains. She finds this baffling because she is somebody and she believes she’s been successful so far in her career as a digital storyteller for a public health nonprofit. (Not to mention Maya Angelou and Bill Clinton are also Arkansas natives.)


For Denmark and McAdoo, there’s an underlying implication coming from the rest of the nation that just by default, the South should be a place any young person should aim to leave. Especially any young Black person. The stereotype goes there is no place more anti-Black, more literacy-challenged, more conservative-leaning than Southern states. Even in larger Southern cities, which trend more liberal, religiosity and rigid gender norms often influence more socially conservative mindsets among Black Southerners who cast blue voting ballots. In both young women’s experience, their travels to other states and countries have not given them enough evidence how they navigate their burgeoning adulthood would be made easier simply because they now live in a place that isn’t the U.S. South.


As Tressie McMillan Cottom often reminds readers of her New York Times column and her many social media followers, the South itself is but a mirror of the greater culture of America. The way so many Americans use it as a scapegoat is indicative of this. The vast majority of Black Americans live in the South. It’s where one can find the most concentrated Black political leadership with voting blocs that have no choice but to force national politics to at least consider the Black “plight.” She argues this dismissiveness of the Southern region of the country reveals a broader distaste for the reality the country has to still engage those people in the first place.


For young women like McAdoo and Denmark, starting their lives in the same Southern states where they were born reminds them of the depth of Black culture foundational to much of modern-day life in the U.S. There isn’t a midnight train to New York that will allow them to outrun racism, sexism or capitalism. For them, it makes sense to find reprieve from the burdens placed on young Black women in the homeland that’s always brought them comfort, culture and community.





Comments


bottom of page