top of page

'A Different World,’ the same devaluation of Black women’s labor

5 hours ago
5 min read

Spelman fires cleaning contractors after 15 years, bringing an HBCU class syllabus on labor to life 


On a red-brick wall, with "Spelman College" affixed in raised letters, a young Black woman leans back and looks up at the camera.
Spelman students must decide whether to voice concerns on the path the school is taking Image credit: AP Photo/Branden Camp

I’m teaching the History of Black Political Thought to juniors and seniors at Morehouse College. In my class we cover Black political thought in 20-year intervals starting in the 1860s, when the Atlanta University Center (AUC) schools started paternalistically popping up, up to today. This semester we’re covering the 1881 Atlanta washerwomen strike and how organized Black women asserted their power through collective action in a way we could only hope to reignite. I’m looking forward to experiencing how these students respond to learning for the first time about that history and how it connects to today. As I finish my first year as an exploited worker at the AUC and a new member of the American Association of University Professors, it hasn’t taken long for the syllabus to come alive, even for me.  


[A] Black college led by a Black woman changed contractors and dozens of unionized Black women lost their livelihoods. Spelman cannot separate its institutional commitments from the working conditions of the women who sustain its campus. “Different” can also mean worse. 

No jobs, no severance: Spelman dissolves relationship with long-time cleaners


In the summer of 2026, Spelman College changed its cleaning contractor from Aramark to Integrity National Corporation. According to Workers United, the union representing the displaced Black women, the new contractor hired almost none of the existing workers. Roughly 35 workers lost their jobs, seniority and union protections. Some had worked on the campus for more than 15 years and received no severance. Workers United contends their union membership played a role in the decision not to rehire them.   Whatever motivated the new contractor’s hiring decisions, the consequences are clear: a Black college led by a Black woman changed contractors and dozens of unionized Black women lost their livelihoods. Spelman cannot separate its institutional commitments from the working conditions of the women who sustain its campus. “Different” can also mean worse. 


Spelman College should provide the 35 displaced workers either an equivalent job on campus or severance pay equal to one week for every year of service. They are asking for a permanent worker-protection policy requiring any contractor operating on campus to provide a living wage of at least $20 per hour, affordable health insurance, an employer-funded retirement plan, job and seniority protections when Spelman changes contractors, and neutrality during union organizing drives. Workers should not lose their livelihoods because Spelman College changes contractors.


I keep seeing and hearing about “A Different World” and its iteration of media tie-in events on campus. Spelman leadership had the show’s reboot filmed on campus. But this seems like the same white world war that devalues Black and Brown women and those who come from them. Spelman leadership may have taken Aretha Franklin’s intro theme song lyrics too literally when they  claim to be preparing their students to build a different world for.  


History repeats itself?


More than a century and a half ago, Sarah J. Thomas was an aspiring student of Atlanta University who used her critical thinking and writing ability to write herself into a degree and protection, and her mother a job at Atlanta University. Thomas graduated in 1875. Six years later, 20 Black laundresses in Atlanta organized over wages and control of their labor and ultimately grew their movement to 3,000. They set prices collectively. They refused to compete against each other.  They built collective power outside of and despite every formal structure designed to exclude them. 145 years later, in this very same Atlanta, Georgia, we are experimenting to see whether the descendants of those working women – students at the AUC in 2026 – can see themselves in those washerwomen, or whether an institution of higher learning has separated them from that inheritance. This is the problem we’ve intended to solve this year in my classroom.


 An investigation: What in the world do HBCUs prepare her students for?


At the HBCU where he teaches, someone told my colleague, Dr. Jared Ball, his role as a Black college professor is to produce menial laborers for the industry his department serves. While no one has said those exact words to me during my time teaching at Morehouse, I’ve observed enough to understand what Ball’s project, "Not a Different World," could reveal about the purpose of Black higher education and whose interests it serves at this moment in history.


Through a whistle-blower-style investigation, Ball examines the modern HBCU as a 21st century exemplar of “neo-colonial education.” He’s seeking and conducting interviews with current and former HBCU students, staff, faculty and administrators to critically assess the institutions’ stated purposes, actual practices and the material conditions of the people who sustain them.


In 2026, on these HBCU campuses, who understand the corportization of their instituions seem rare. The environment more closely resembles the one Ball’s project investigates than the vision of John Lewis depicted in murals on these same walls, calling students toward “good trouble.”   What the washerwomen understood in 1881, and what these displaced Spelman workers understand now is that labor cannot be separated from power. That relationship is essential to how we teach and discuss Black political thought. When Spelman changed contractors, 35 workers absorbed the consequences of an institutional decision they had no part in making. Replacing a unionized workforce with a largely non-union one threatens precisely what the washerwomen organized to secure – workers’ collective power to negotiate the conditions of their labor without facing employers individually.


There’s nothing particularly radical about these women’s demands, though so many people misunderstand “radical” as something beyond the pale, rather than a return to the root of the problem. The workers are demanding protections any institution professing to Black people should provide.


Taking labor organizing from the textbook to reality


As a professor of political science at Morehouse, after two years of community organizing in southwest Atlanta (including the AUC), I can tell stories of the women being impacted by institutions that claim to be established for their wellbeing, and those who are building institutions that develop and protect all of us. I hope my efforts this year, alongside a few comrades who are administration, faculty, staff, students and community members, remind Black leaders coming out of the AUC that they are workers. They are the laboring class. Their ancestors never desired to be enslaver-capitalists. Neither was there ever a time their ancestors stopped fighting for power over their lives and futures. What we are tasked with is helping Black girls and boys sling off the ideas about labor its enemies have taught us.


Sarah J. Thomas could likely never imagined a world where those who followed her as a working person would displace Black women who are mothers and grandmothers, working in the same industry, in the same city, 145 years later. We are overdue for a different world, one in which there are consequences for Black “mis”leadership enacting war on Black working women and their ability to live dignified lives.   The AUC encourages students to make good trouble. I encourage everyone with any connection to the AUC who wants Black people to never stop demanding positive social change, to stand with these workers, especially when Black women are the ones making the demands.   My class follows the guide Black women like Harriet Tubman, Ida B Wells and Claudia Jones have laid for us. At the rally outside Spelman’s gates, I stood with women who had given years of their labor to an institution that no longer had a place for them. They looked tired and demoralized. They’d given their labor and left their wealth somewhere on the inside. Help walk them back into the gates. 



Comments


bottom of page